Be In The Know

rss logo RSS Feed
Buying | 65 Posts
Real Estate News | 43 Posts
Selling | 45 Posts
October
13

A Phase I environmental site assessment is the inquiry that federal rule 40 CFR Part 312 calls "all appropriate inquiries," and a buyer who wants protection from CERCLA cleanup liability has to complete it within one year before the date of acquisition. Five parts of it must be refreshed within 180 days before the buyer takes title. EPA's own Brownfields page names ASTM E1527-21 as one of two standards that satisfy the rule. If you are weighing commercial real estate in Rockford, this is the federal step to understand before the purchase date is set.

None of the official pages used for this guide is specific to Rockford. The inquiry standard is a federal rule, and Illinois runs a voluntary cleanup program that picks up where a Phase I leaves off. This guide explains what those two sets of rules say, in the order a buyer meets them. It is not legal or environmental advice, and the attorney and the environmental professional on your purchase confirm how the rules apply to your property.

What The Rule Is And Which Standard Satisfies It

EPA's Brownfields page defines the process in one sentence. All appropriate inquiries is the process of evaluating a property's environmental conditions and assessing potential liability for any contamination. The reason the process exists is strict liability. Under CERCLA, the federal Superfund law, a person can be held liable for cleaning up hazardous substances at a property they currently own or operate, or owned or operated in the past. EPA explains that strict liability means liability may be assigned based solely on property ownership.

Congress addressed that exposure in the 2002 Brownfields Amendments to CERCLA. The amendments gave certain landowners and prospective owners who did not cause or contribute to contamination a way to be protected, and they required EPA to write regulations setting the standards for the inquiry. EPA published the final rule in the Federal Register on November 1, 2005, and it went into effect on November 1, 2006.

The rule does not prescribe a form. EPA describes it as a performance-based standard. The objective is to inquire into past uses and ownerships of a property and to visually inspect it, so that conditions indicative of releases and threatened releases of hazardous substances come to light. The rule also points to industry standards that meet its requirements. Under the current text of 40 CFR 312.11, those are ASTM International Standard E1527-21, titled "Standard Practice for Environmental Site Assessments: Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Process," and E2247-23, the version written for forestland and rural property. EPA's page states that either standard can be used to obtain protection as an innocent landowner, a contiguous property owner or a bona fide prospective purchaser.

The version number matters because the older one has an end date. The same section of the regulation lists the previous standard, E1527-13, as usable only until February 13, 2024. It lists the earlier rural standard, E2247-16, as usable only until June 24, 2025. The amendment history under the section cites a Federal Register notice of December 15, 2022, and another of June 24, 2024. If a report on a property you are considering was prepared under E1527-13, ask the environmental professional whether it meets the current text of the rule before you rely on it.

Who has to meet the rule? EPA's page says the requirements apply to commercial and government entities purchasing property, and to all individuals purchasing property for non-residential use, who may seek protection from CERCLA liability after the purchase. The same page says a party that receives an EPA Brownfields grant and uses it for site characterization or assessment must also follow the rule, and that every Phase I paid for with Brownfields Assessment Grant funds must comply with Part 312.

One more point about scope. The rule is written around hazardous substances. For buyers it does not expand to cover every possible concern on a site. EPA's page lists lead-based paint, mold, radon, asbestos, regulatory compliance assessment and indoor air quality as examples of non-scope considerations that a buyer and a consultant can contract for separately, along with Phase II sampling and analysis. If your plan for the building depends on any of those, they belong in the written scope of work, because the baseline inquiry is not built to answer them.

The Two Clocks: One Year And 180 Days

The timing rule has two parts, and it is easy to read them as one. The first is the outer limit. Under 312.20(a), the inquiry must be conducted within one year prior to the date of acquisition. The regulation defines the date of acquisition as the date on which a person acquires title to the property. So the clock runs to the day title passes, not the day a contract is signed.

The second part is a shorter clock on five components. Section 312.20(b) says these must be conducted or updated within 180 days of and prior to the date of acquisition:

  • Interviews with past and present owners, operators and occupants.
  • Searches for recorded environmental cleanup liens.
  • Reviews of federal, tribal, state and local government records.
  • Visual inspections of the facility and of adjoining properties.
  • The declaration by the environmental professional.

Here is how the two clocks work together, as an illustration of the regulation's wording and not a prediction about any deal. Suppose a consultant completes a full report, and the buyer closes 200 days after the site visit. The report is inside the one-year limit. But the interviews, the records review, the lien search, the inspection and the declaration were all done more than 180 days before title passed, so those five components have to be updated before closing. A buyer who signs a contract with a long due-diligence period and a long closing window can end up in exactly that position.

The regulation also allows a buyer to use earlier work. Under 312.20(c), an inquiry can include information from an earlier inquiry conducted by or for the same person, if the information was collected or updated within one year before acquisition, the five 180-day components were updated within 180 days, and the older information is brought current for changes in the condition of the property and in the specialized knowledge of the people conducting the inquiry. Under 312.20(d), a report prepared by or for someone else can be used too, but only if it meets the rule's objectives and performance factors, the buyer reviews it, the buyer does the additional inquiries described later in this guide, and the five components are updated as needed. A seller's old report is therefore a starting point, and it does not by itself carry the buyer's protection.

The clocks measure how recent the inquiry must be before a particular acquisition. Put the report date, the site visit date and the target closing date side by side, because the 180-day components are measured against the day title passes.

Who Does The Work And What The Inquiry Covers

The regulation splits the work between two parties. The environmental professional carries out the core inquiry. The buyer carries out a short list of inquiries that only the buyer can answer, and the two sets of information are combined in one written report.

Start with the professional. Section 312.10 defines an environmental professional as a person with the specific education, training and experience to exercise professional judgment about conditions indicative of releases or threatened releases on, at, in or to a property. The regulation gives four ways to qualify:

  • A current Professional Engineer's or Professional Geologist's license or registration, plus the equivalent of three years of full-time relevant experience.
  • A license or certification from the federal government, a state, a tribe or a territory to perform environmental inquiries, plus three years of full-time relevant experience.
  • A bachelor's degree or higher in a discipline of engineering or science, plus five years of full-time relevant experience.
  • Ten years of full-time relevant experience.

A person who does not meet the definition may still assist, but only under the supervision or responsible charge of someone who does. The regulation adds that the definition does not preempt state licensing or registration rules, and that a person should check those rules before starting work. When you select a consultant, ask who is the named environmental professional on the report, and which of the four routes they qualify under.

The professional's inquiry has six parts under 312.21(b). Each has its own section of the regulation.

Interviews come first. The current owner and occupant of the property must be interviewed. If there are several occupants, the professional interviews the major ones and those likely to use, store, treat, handle or dispose of hazardous substances, or likely to have done so in the past. The regulation also calls for one or more of the following where needed: current and past facility managers, past owners, occupants or operators, and employees of current and past occupants. For an abandoned property with evidence of unauthorized use or uncontrolled access, the interviews extend to one or more neighboring owners or occupants.

Historical sources come second. The regulation lists aerial photographs, fire insurance maps, building department records, chain of title documents and land use records as examples. The review must reach back as far as it can be shown that the property contained structures, or to the time it was first used for residential, agricultural, commercial, industrial or governmental purposes. The professional may use judgment about how far back to search, based on the facts available at the time.

Government records come third, and this part has numbers in it. For the property itself, the review covers records of reported releases, landfill and disposal unit records, storage tank records, hazardous waste handler records, lists of priority cleanup sites, spill reports, and registries of engineering controls and institutional controls. For nearby and adjoining properties, section 312.26(c) sets search distances:

  • One mile for National Priorities List sites or state equivalents, and for RCRA facilities subject to corrective action.
  • One-half mile for sites in state voluntary cleanup programs and state-listed brownfields, for leaking underground storage tanks, for delisted NPL sites, for engineering control registries, for former CERCLIS sites with no further remedial action notices, and for permitted landfills and solid waste facilities.
  • Adjoining property only for RCRA small and large quantity generators and for registered storage tanks.

The professional can change those distances using judgment, for reasons such as the nature of a release or the direction groundwater flows, but the rationale for the change must be documented.

Visual inspection comes fourth. The professional must inspect the property on site, including areas where hazardous substances may be or may have been used, stored, treated, handled or disposed. Adjoining properties are inspected from the property line, a public right-of-way or another vantage point such as aerial photography. Physical limits on either inspection must be noted. The on-site inspection can be skipped only in an unusual circumstance, such as a remote or inaccessible location, after good-faith efforts to get access. The regulation says that the mere refusal of a voluntary seller to provide access is not an unusual circumstance. A buyer who is told by a seller that the consultant cannot enter the building should know that the regulation does not treat that as a reason to skip the inspection.

The fifth and sixth parts are commonly known or reasonably ascertainable information, and the degree of obviousness of contamination and the ability to detect it. For the first, the professional may look to owners or occupants of neighboring properties, local and state officials, others with knowledge of the property, and sources such as newspapers, web sites, community organizations, local libraries and historical societies. For the second, the professional weighs everything collected and gives an opinion on whether additional appropriate investigation is warranted.

Now the buyer's part. Under 312.22, the person seeking protection must carry out four inquiries and may pass the results to the professional. The first is a search for environmental cleanup liens filed or recorded under federal, tribal, state or local law. The second is to account for the buyer's own specialized knowledge of the property, the surrounding area and the adjoining properties. The regulation states that the inquiries "are not complete" unless the results take that knowledge into account. The third is to consider whether the purchase price reasonably reflects the fair market value of the property if it were not contaminated, and, if it does not, whether the gap is due to releases or threatened releases. The fourth is to gather commonly known or reasonably ascertainable information.

What The Report Must Say And What Protection It Supports

The results go into a written report. Under 312.21(c), at a minimum the report has three things. It gives an opinion on whether the inquiry identified conditions indicative of releases or threatened releases of hazardous substances on, at, in or to the property. It identifies data gaps, which the regulation defines as a lack of or inability to obtain required information despite good-faith efforts, and comments on how significant they are. And it states the qualifications of the environmental professional. If data gaps prevent the professional from reaching an opinion, they must be noted in the opinion itself.

The professional signs the report and includes two declarations from 312.21(d). One says they meet the definition of an environmental professional. The other says they have the specific qualifications to assess a property of that nature, history and setting, and that they performed the inquiry in conformance with 40 CFR Part 312. This signed declaration is one of the five components on the 180-day clock.

EPA says the rule does not require any specific format, length or structure. Its page lists suggested sections, from an introduction and site description through records review, site reconnaissance, interviews, findings, opinion, data gaps, conclusions and appendices, and says they are not regulatory requirements. The ASTM E1527-21 standard is more specific about one thing. It requires a conclusion statement substantially like one of two forms, either that the assessment revealed no evidence of recognized environmental conditions in connection with the property, or that it revealed none "except for the following" followed by a list. When you read a report, that statement is the line to find first. If a list follows it, each item is a condition to discuss with the professional and your attorney before closing.

What does completing the inquiry buy? EPA's page names the protections. An innocent landowner must show, among other requirements, that before buying they "did not know and had no reason to know" that hazardous substances were disposed of on the property. A contiguous property owner owns land next to a facility that is the only source of contamination found on the owner's property, and must also show no reason to know before purchase. A bona fide prospective purchaser may buy with knowledge of contamination if the purchase came after January 11, 2002 and the statutory criteria are met. EPA's Common Elements page adds that only the bona fide prospective purchaser can buy a property with known contamination, including one on the National Priorities List or in an active cleanup, and keep the protection. The other two cannot.

Doing the inquiry is not the end of the obligations. EPA states that an owner claiming any of the three protections must conduct the inquiry before acquiring the property and comply with all continuing obligations after acquiring it. The Common Elements page lists them:

  • No disposal of hazardous substances after acquisition.
  • Compliance with land use restrictions, and no interference with institutional controls.
  • Taking "reasonable steps" with respect to hazardous substances.
  • Full cooperation, assistance and access for the people authorized to conduct response actions.
  • Compliance with information requests and administrative subpoenas.
  • Providing legally required notices.

EPA defines reasonable steps as stopping continuing releases, preventing threatened future releases, and preventing or limiting human, environmental or natural resource exposure to earlier releases. A bona fide prospective purchaser and a contiguous property owner must also show they are not potentially liable, or affiliated with anyone who is. EPA's page says affiliation includes family relationships, contractual, corporate or financial relationships, and the result of a business reorganization, with an exception for relationships created by the instruments that convey or finance title or by a contract for the sale of goods or services.

Two more federal points bear on commercial deals. First, EPA's page on bona fide prospective purchasers explains the windfall lien. Where an EPA-funded cleanup increased the fair market value of a property, the United States may pursue a lien on a bona fide prospective purchaser's property for the lesser of the unrecovered cleanup costs or the increase in value. Second, a 2018 law, the BUILD Act, extended bona fide prospective purchaser status to a tenant who acquires a leasehold interest, under three alternative conditions listed on the same page. A tenant reading those conditions can ask an attorney which one fits.

Illinois has its own layer. The Illinois EPA runs the Site Remediation Program, a voluntary cleanup program under 35 Illinois Administrative Code Parts 740 and 742. Participation that succeeds ends in a No Further Remediation letter. The agency's overview describes that letter as a release from further responsibilities under the Illinois Environmental Protection Act and prima facie evidence that the site does not constitute a significant risk of harm to human health and the environment, so long as the site is used in accordance with the letter's terms. The letter must be filed with the county Recorder or Registrar of Titles, so it becomes part of the chain of title and tells later owners what its terms are. Some letters carry conditions such as institutional controls or engineered barriers. For how that office's deed, lien and title records work in Winnebago County, see the guide to the Winnebago County Recorder.

The program has eligibility limits and costs. A site is not eligible if it is on the National Priorities List, if the work is required under a current RCRA permit or closure, if it is required under underground storage tank laws such as leaking tank sites, or if a federal court order or USEPA order requires it. Enrollment takes an application and services agreement plus an advance partial payment of 2,500 dollars, or an agency cost estimate and an advance payment of no more than 5,000 dollars or half of the anticipated costs, whichever is less, and advance payments are not refundable. The agency says it approves or denies an application within 30 days of receipt. All site work, plans and reports must be done by or under an Illinois licensed professional engineer, and the agency has 60 days from receipt to review a plan or report.

The program's link back to a Phase I is specific. To seek the comprehensive letter, an applicant prepares a Comprehensive Site Investigation documented as a two-phase environmental assessment. The overview says the Phase I must follow ASTM E1527-00 unless the Illinois EPA approves an alternative. That standard is older than the E1527-21 named in the federal rule. Anyone planning to enter the program should confirm with the Illinois EPA which Phase I standard it will accept for their project, and should expect the Phase II to involve sampling and analysis to characterize any contaminants. The overview says that an applicant who is not the site owner needs the owner's written permission to enroll.

Bottom Line

A Phase I is the inquiry the federal rule calls all appropriate inquiries, and for a commercial buyer it is the step that has to happen before closing if CERCLA protection is the goal. It must be completed within one year before title passes, with interviews, government records, lien searches, the site inspection and the professional's declaration refreshed within 180 days. ASTM E1527-21 and E2247-23 are the standards the rule names, and the older E1527-13 stopped being accepted on February 13, 2024.

The inquiry has to be done by, or under the supervision of, an environmental professional who meets one of the four routes in the regulation. The buyer has to supply what only the buyer can: the lien search, specialized knowledge of the property, a view on whether the price makes sense for an uncontaminated site, and anything commonly known about it. The report has to give an opinion, name its data gaps and carry the professional's signed declarations. Protection then depends on continuing obligations after closing, including taking reasonable steps and honoring any land use restriction.

If a report finds something, the Illinois Site Remediation Program is the state's route to a recorded No Further Remediation letter, and it asks for a licensed engineer and a Phase II. Before you commit to a building, read the report's conclusion statement, put the site visit date next to the closing date, and ask your attorney and the environmental professional how the rule applies to your property. When you are ready to look at commercial real estate in Rockford, bring those dates and that report to the conversation. For the land-use side of the same purchase, see the guides on Rockford commercial zoning districts and on the Rockford enterprise zone and TIF districts, and the full list in the Illinois Real Estate Guide. Gambino Realtors has worked in the Rockford area since 1923.

These are the questions that come up once a buyer has read a Phase I or is deciding whether to order one.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is a Phase I environmental site assessment good for?

The federal rule sets the age limit relative to the purchase, not a shelf life. The inquiry must be conducted within one year before the date of acquisition, which is the date title passes. Interviews, government records reviews, the visual inspection, the cleanup lien search and the environmental professional's declaration must each be conducted or updated within 180 days before that date. If closing slips past those windows, those components have to be updated.

Which ASTM standard should a commercial buyer ask for?

EPA's Brownfields page and 40 CFR 312.11 name ASTM E1527-21 and E2247-23 as standards consistent with the federal rule. E1527-21 is the Phase I process standard. E2247-23 is the version for forestland and rural property. The regulation lists E1527-13 as usable only until February 13, 2024, so a report prepared under that older version needs a check with the environmental professional before you rely on it.

Who is allowed to perform a Phase I?

The core inquiry is done by an environmental professional, or by someone working under that professional's supervision or responsible charge. The regulation gives four routes: a professional engineer or geologist license plus three years of full-time experience, a government license or certification to perform environmental inquiries plus three years, an engineering or science bachelor's degree plus five years, or ten years of full-time relevant experience. State licensing rules still apply.

What does the buyer have to do, besides hiring a consultant?

The buyer has four inquiries under 40 CFR 312.22. Search for environmental cleanup liens, account for the buyer's own specialized knowledge of the property and surrounding area, consider whether the purchase price reasonably reflects the fair market value if the property were not contaminated, and gather commonly known or reasonably ascertainable information. The regulation says the inquiries are not complete unless the buyer's specialized knowledge is taken into account.

Can a seller refuse to let the consultant inside the building?

A seller can refuse, but the regulation does not treat that as a reason to skip the on-site inspection. Section 312.27 says the mere refusal of a voluntary seller to provide access does not constitute an unusual circumstance. The inspection can be replaced only where physical limitations, a remote or inaccessible location or another inability to get access remain after good-faith efforts, and the efforts have to be documented in the report.

Does a Phase I protect me forever after I close?

No. EPA states that an owner claiming innocent landowner, contiguous property owner or bona fide prospective purchaser protection must do the inquiry before acquiring the property and comply with all continuing obligations afterward. Those include no disposal after acquisition, compliance with land use restrictions, taking reasonable steps, cooperating with response actors, answering information requests and providing legally required notices.

What is a No Further Remediation letter in Illinois?

It is the result of successful participation in the Illinois EPA's voluntary Site Remediation Program. The agency describes it as a release from further responsibilities under the Illinois Environmental Protection Act and prima facie evidence that the site does not constitute a significant risk of harm, so long as the site is used in accordance with the letter. It must be filed with the county Recorder or Registrar of Titles and may carry conditions such as institutional controls.

Login to My Homefinder