Be In The Know

rss logo RSS Feed
Buying | 65 Posts
Real Estate News | 43 Posts
Selling | 45 Posts
October
19

A Section 1031 exchange lets an owner of rental or commercial real estate swap one investment property for another without recognizing gain on the swap, and the IRS gives it two clocks: 45 days to identify the replacement property and 180 days to receive it. The clocks start the day the first property is transferred. Missing a deadline can make the gain taxable in the year of the transfer.

This guide walks through the federal rules as the IRS publishes them, so an owner thinking about trading a duplex, a small apartment building or a commercial building can understand the vocabulary before talking to a tax professional. Gambino Realtors has been based in Rockford since 1923, and our page on multi-family properties in Rockford shows the kind of buildings owners most often ask about. Everything below comes from three IRS pages: the real estate tax tips on like-kind exchanges, the Instructions for Form 8824, and Publication 544. This is not legal or tax advice. A CPA, enrolled agent or tax attorney applies these rules to a particular sale, and nothing here covers Illinois income tax.

What A 1031 Exchange Is, And What Counts As Property

The IRS describes a like-kind exchange as an exchange of real property used for business or held as an investment, solely for other business or investment property of the same type. The general rule is that when you make one, you are not required to recognize a gain or loss under Section 1031. The word "defer" fits better than "avoid," because the basis of the property you receive generally carries over from the property you gave up. In the example Publication 544 uses, an investor whose old property had an adjusted basis of 225,000 dollars ends up with a new property that has a basis of 225,000 dollars. The tax is postponed into the new property. It is not erased.

Two limits matter before anything else. First, the rule now covers real property only. The IRS explains that under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, Section 1031 applies only to exchanges of real property and not to personal or intangible property, and that since January 1, 2018 exchanges of machinery, equipment, vehicles, artwork, collectibles, patents and similar assets generally do not qualify. An owner who sells a building with a truck and a set of tools cannot fold the truck and tools into the exchange. Second, the property has to be held for use in a trade or business or for investment. Real property held primarily for sale does not qualify. Real property used for personal purposes, such as your home, is outside the rule as well.

The "like-kind" test is about the nature of the property, not its quality. Properties are of like kind if they have the same nature or character, even if they differ in grade or quality. Real properties generally are like-kind whether they are improved or unimproved. The IRS gives a plain example: an apartment building would generally be like-kind to another apartment building. By the same reading, vacant land can be exchanged for a building, because both are real property. The one geographic limit is that real property in the United States is not like-kind to real property outside the United States.

What the IRS counts as real property comes from Treasury Regulations section 1.1031(a)-3. That regulation defines real property as land and improvements to land, unsevered natural products of the land, and water and air space above the land. A tangible asset qualifies if it is classified as real property under the law of the state or local jurisdiction where it sits, if the regulation lists it as real property, or if it passes the facts-and-circumstances factors. Each distinct asset is analyzed on its own. Property permanently affixed to real property, expected to stay affixed for an indefinite period, is generally treated as an inherently permanent structure. A structural component built into such a structure is real property too, whether or not it produces income.

The regulation also names what never counts. Stock, bonds and notes, other securities, interests in a partnership (with a narrow exception for partnerships that have elected out of the partnership rules), certificates of trust and beneficial interests are never real property for Section 1031. Stock in a cooperative housing corporation is the stated exception that does count as real property. So a building can be exchanged, but a partnership interest generally cannot.

Homes and apartments get their own paragraph in Publication 544. A dwelling unit, meaning a home, apartment, condominium or similar property, may qualify as held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment if certain requirements are met, and the IRS points to Revenue Procedure 2008-16 for those requirements. Publication 544 lists buildings, land and rental property as examples of property that may qualify. The Form 8824 instructions add one more caution: Section 1031 does not apply to certain exchanges involving tax-exempt use property subject to a lease.

If the property you give up was your own home, the picture changes. The IRS says Section 1031 does not apply when the property given up was used solely as your personal residence at the time of the exchange. If you owned and used it as your main home for at least a total of 2 years during the 5-year period ending on the date of the exchange, the separate Section 121 exclusion may cover part or all of the gain. For a property used partly as a home and partly for business or investment, the instructions have you use two separate Forms 8824 as worksheets. Those are questions for a tax professional, because the answer depends on how the building was actually used.

Not every exchange happens on one day. The simplest version is a swap where the two owners trade deeds at the same closing. The version most investors use is a deferred exchange, which the IRS defines as one where, based on an agreement, the property received is received after the transfer of the property given up. That delay is what creates the two clocks, and it is where most of the risk sits.

The 45-Day And 180-Day Clocks, And The Qualified Intermediary

In a deferred exchange, the replacement property must be identified within 45 days after the property being given up is transferred. It must be received within 180 days, or by the due date of the tax return for that year including extensions, whichever is earlier. The second limit catches people off guard. If the tax return due date for the year of the transfer arrives before the 180th day, that earlier date controls. Publication 544 calls the first period the identification period and the second the exchange period. Both start on the day of the transfer, and the 180 days run at the same time as the 45, not after them.

If you transfer more than one property as part of the same transaction on different dates, both periods begin on the date of the earliest transfer. The IRS also notes that property received during the identification period is considered identified, and the Form 8824 instructions add that if you receive the replacement property before the 45 days end, you are automatically treated as having met the written identification requirement.

Identification is a paperwork step with specific rules. You must identify the replacement property in a signed written document and deliver it to the person obligated to transfer the replacement property, or to any other person involved in the exchange other than you or a disqualified person. The description has to be clear. Publication 544 says to use the legal description or street address, and the Form 8824 instructions allow a distinguishable name, with "Mayfair Apartment Building" as the sample. The instructions also allow all parties to sign a written agreement that designates the replacement property. You can cancel an identification in the same manner at any time before the 45 days end.

An investor can name more than one candidate, which is useful because a purchase can fall through. The limit, according to Publication 544, is the larger of two tests. You can identify three properties regardless of their fair market value. Or you can identify any number of properties whose total fair market value at the end of the identification period is not more than double the total fair market value, on the date of transfer, of everything you gave up. If you name more than either test allows, the only property treated as identified is what you received before the 45 days ended, plus property you identified and then received before the 180-day period ended, but only if its fair market value is at least 95 percent of the total value of everything you identified.

Suppose an owner sells a rental building for an agreed value of one million dollars. Under the double-value test the owner could identify any number of properties up to a combined fair market value of two million dollars. Under the three-property test the owner could name three properties of any value. An owner who names four properties worth a combined three million dollars has broken both tests, so only the property actually received within the 45 days, or one worth at least 95 percent of the whole list, is protected. The figures only illustrate how the tests work.

Furniture and equipment that normally go with a building do not need their own line on the list. Publication 544 says incidental property is not treated as separate from the larger item for identification if it is typically transferred with the larger item in a standard commercial transaction and its total fair market value is not more than 15 percent of the larger item. Its example is furniture, laundry machines and other personal property with an apartment building worth one million dollars, as long as the personal property does not exceed 150,000 dollars. The IRS is explicit that this rule applies only to identification. It does not decide whether that personal property is like-kind for purposes of any gain.

The replacement property does not have to exist yet. Publication 544 says gain or loss from a deferred exchange can qualify even if the replacement property is not in existence or is being produced when you identify it, and it tells you to estimate fair market value as of the date you expect to receive it. There are limits. The property you receive has to be substantially the same property you identified. Substantial changes can disqualify it, and any additional production after you receive the property does not qualify as like-kind property.

The qualified intermediary exists because of one problem. If, before you receive the replacement property, you actually or constructively receive money or other non-like-kind property in full payment for what you transferred, the IRS treats the transaction as a sale. It does so even if you later receive the replacement property. Constructive receipt is broad. Money is constructively received when it is credited to your account, set apart for you, or otherwise made available so you can draw upon it at any time. Receipt by your agent counts as receipt by you. An owner who has the sale proceeds credited to a personal account has money made available to draw upon at any time, which is the situation the rule describes.

The IRS lists four arrangements that do not count as receipt: security or guarantee arrangements, qualified escrow accounts or qualified trusts, qualified intermediaries, and interest or growth factors. The qualified intermediary is the one most investors use. Under Publication 544, if you transfer property through a qualified intermediary, the transfer of the property given up and the receipt of the replacement property is treated as an exchange, even if you receive money or other property directly from a party other than the intermediary.

The definition is specific. A qualified intermediary is a person who is not a disqualified person and who enters into a written exchange agreement with you. As that agreement requires, the intermediary acquires and transfers the property you give up and acquires and transfers the replacement property to you. The written exchange agreement must expressly limit your rights to receive, pledge, borrow or otherwise obtain the benefits of the money or unlike property the intermediary holds. In other words, the contract itself has to keep the cash out of your reach.

Who cannot serve is just as important. A disqualified person is your agent at the time of the transaction, a person related to you, or a person related to your agent. The IRS says related parties and agents are not eligible to be intermediaries. A person who acted as your employee, attorney, accountant, investment banker or broker, or real estate agent or broker within the 2-year period ending on the date you transfer the first property is treated as your agent. Services on exchanges meant to qualify under Section 1031 are not counted for that purpose, and neither are routine financial, title insurance, escrow or trust services from a financial institution, title insurance company or escrow company. The practical point is that the party holding the money is chosen early, and it should be someone the IRS will not treat as you.

Where Exchanges Go Wrong, And What Gets Reported

The first failure is a missed deadline, and the IRS is blunt about who bears the cost. If you fail to meet the timing requirements because of the qualified intermediary, your transaction will not qualify as a deferred exchange, and any gain may be taxable in the year you transferred the property. There is one narrow relief. If the intermediary defaults on its obligation to acquire and transfer replacement property because of bankruptcy or receivership proceedings, and you meet the requirements of Revenue Procedure 2010-14, you may be able to report the gain in the year or years payments are received. That relief depends on meeting the Revenue Procedure.

The second failure is taking cash. Section 1031 gives full deferral only when the exchange is solely for like-kind property. If you also receive money or other property that is not like-kind, the IRS calls it a partially nontaxable exchange, and you must recognize gain to the extent of the money and the fair market value of the other property received. You can never recognize a loss. Publication 544 works through an example. An investor exchanges real estate worth 110,000 dollars with an adjusted basis of 80,000 dollars for other real estate worth 100,000 dollars, receives 10,000 dollars in cash and pays 5,000 dollars in exchange expenses. The realized gain is 25,000 dollars, but the recognized, taxable gain is only 5,000 dollars, which is the cash received less the expenses paid.

Liabilities work like cash in this arithmetic. If the other party assumes a liability of yours, such as the mortgage on the old building, you are generally treated as receiving money in that amount. You can reduce the amount treated as received by liabilities you assume and by any cash you pay or non-like-kind property you give up. The rule is why a change in the debt on the two buildings is something to review with a tax professional. Any recognized gain is reported on Form 8949, Schedule D or Form 4797, as applicable, and the IRS notes it may be ordinary income from depreciation recapture.

Closing costs matter in the same arithmetic. Exchange expenses generally include the costs you pay to dispose of the property given up, such as brokerage commissions, attorney fees and deed preparation fees. They also include closing costs you pay to acquire the replacement property. Subtracting them reduces the amount realized, which is why the example above subtracts them from the cash received. For anyone planning the numbers, our guide to transfer taxes and closing costs in Rockford explains the closing items on the local side.

The third failure is dealing with a relative or a related entity without knowing the rule. The Form 8824 instructions say a related party includes your spouse, child, grandchild, parent, grandparent, brother, sister, or a related corporation, S corporation, partnership, trust, estate or tax-exempt organization. The rule reaches indirect exchanges too, such as an exchange with a related party through an intermediary, or one made by a disregarded entity like a single-member LLC that you or a related party owned. An exchange structured to avoid the related party rules is not a like-kind exchange at all, and it is reported as a sale.

Even a permitted related-party exchange carries a waiting period. If you or the related party dispose of the property received before 2 years after the last transfer that was part of the exchange, the deferred gain is reported on the return for the year of the disposition, unless an exception applies. The exceptions are a disposition after the death of either party, an involuntary conversion where the threat occurred after the exchange, and a case where you can establish to the IRS's satisfaction that neither the exchange nor the disposition had tax avoidance as a principal purpose. The 2-year clock starts on the date of the last transfer, and any period when the holder's risk of loss is substantially diminished, for example through a put, a right held by another person to acquire the property, or a short sale, does not count. The owner also files Form 8824 for each of the 2 years that follow a related-party exchange.

The fourth failure is quieter. Owners forget that the exchange has to be reported. If during the tax year you transferred property in a like-kind exchange, you file Form 8824 with your return for that year, and the IRS says to report it even though no gain or loss is recognized.

Local facts sit next to the federal rules and do not change them. Our guide to Rockford multifamily zoning for duplexes and fourplexes covers the zoning side. Our guide to financing a 2- to 4-unit building covers loan rules for small buildings. Our guide to Rockford rental registration and inspection rules covers what the city asks of a rental.

Bottom Line

A 1031 exchange defers tax. It does not remove it, and it works only on business or investment real property, never on a home, a builder's inventory, or equipment. The rules that decide whether it holds up are mechanical: a signed written identification within 45 days, receipt of the property within 180 days or the tax return due date, whichever is earlier, no actual or constructive receipt of the cash, and a qualified intermediary who is not your agent or a relative. Cash taken out, or debt relieved, is taxed to that extent. Related-party trades carry a 2-year waiting period.

If you own a rental building near Rockford and think an exchange might fit, the order is simple. Talk to a CPA, enrolled agent or tax attorney before you sign a contract to sell, because a qualified intermediary acts under a written exchange agreement and takes part in the transfer of the property you give up. Then look at the replacement candidates early. Our page on multi-family properties in Rockford is a place to start looking, and our Illinois Real Estate Guide lists every Gambino Realtors article for the surrounding questions.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many days do you have in a 1031 exchange?

There are two deadlines, and both start on the day you transfer the property you are giving up. You must identify the replacement property in writing within 45 days. You must receive it within 180 days, or by the due date of your tax return for that year including extensions, whichever is earlier. The 180 days run at the same time as the 45, not after them. If you transfer several properties on different dates, both periods begin on the date of the earliest transfer. If a deadline is missed because of a qualified intermediary, the IRS says the transaction will not qualify as a deferred exchange and the gain may be taxable.

What is a qualified intermediary in a 1031 exchange?

A qualified intermediary is a person who is not a disqualified person and who enters into a written exchange agreement with you. Under that agreement it acquires and transfers the property you give up and acquires and transfers the replacement property to you. The agreement must expressly limit your rights to receive, pledge, borrow or otherwise obtain the benefits of the money held by the intermediary. If you use one, the IRS treats the transfer and the receipt as an exchange, even if you receive money or other property directly from a party other than the intermediary.

Can my real estate agent or attorney act as the qualified intermediary?

Generally no. The IRS says related parties and agents of the taxpayer are not eligible to be qualified intermediaries. Publication 544 treats a person who acted as your employee, attorney, accountant, investment banker or broker, or real estate agent or broker within the 2-year period ending on the date you transfer the first property as your agent. Services connected with exchanges meant to qualify under Section 1031 are not counted for that test, and neither are routine financial, title insurance, escrow or trust services from a financial institution, title insurance company or escrow company.

How many replacement properties can I identify?

Publication 544 allows up to three properties regardless of their fair market value. As an alternative, you may identify any number of properties as long as their total fair market value at the end of the identification period is not more than double the total fair market value, on the transfer date, of the properties you gave up. If you identify more than either test allows, only property you received before the 45 days ended counts, plus property you identified and received in time if its value is at least 95 percent of everything you identified.

Does a 1031 exchange work for my own home or a house I am flipping?

No for both, as the IRS describes the rule. Section 1031 does not apply to real property used for personal purposes, such as your home, and it does not apply to real property held primarily for sale. The Form 8824 instructions say that if the property you gave up was your main home for at least a total of 2 years during the 5-year period before the exchange, a different rule, Section 121, may exclude part or all of the gain. A rental house can qualify as property held for investment if certain requirements are met, and a CPA can confirm whether yours does.

What happens if I take some cash out of the exchange?

The cash is taxed to the extent of the gain. If you receive money or other property that is not like-kind along with the replacement property, the IRS calls it a partially nontaxable exchange. You recognize gain up to the amount of money and the fair market value of the other property received, and you cannot recognize a loss. Publication 544 gives an example where the realized gain is 25,000 dollars but only 5,000 dollars is recognized, because 10,000 dollars in cash was received and 5,000 dollars of exchange expenses were paid. Recognized gain is reported on Form 8949, Schedule D or Form 4797, as applicable.

Does Section 1031 apply to equipment, vehicles or a business that comes with the building?

Not since 2018. The IRS explains that Section 1031 now applies only to exchanges of real property, and that exchanges of machinery, equipment, vehicles, artwork, collectibles, patents and other intangible business assets generally do not qualify. Personal property that is incidental to a building, such as furniture or laundry machines, is disregarded when you identify the replacement property if it is typically transferred with the building and worth no more than 15 percent of it. That rule is for identification only. It does not make the personal property like-kind for figuring gain.

Login to My Homefinder